Menu
Product review

Newair Countertop Nugget Ice Maker 44 lb (NIM044BSN2) review, scored

Best-documented terms here, but owners rate it far below testers.

Home Catalog editorial team · Fact-checked · Updated

Newair Countertop Nugget Ice Maker 44 lb (NIM044BSN2)
Product photo from Newair

#1 of 11 products in Major Appliances

Calculated from published specs and owner feedback

See all major appliances
  • Overall 7.3
  • Social 6.7
  • Usability 7.8

Strengths and drawbacks

Published specs and owner feedback, not a hands-on test.

Strengths

  • Two-year warranty and free returns
  • Full spec sheet incl. dB and ETL
  • Fastest output in a five-machine test

Drawbacks

  • Low Amazon owner rating
  • Small nuggets
  • Reference prices differ across pages

How the score breaks down

Published features and owner comments · not a lab test.

Published features and owner comments · not a lab test.

  • Overall7.3
  • Social6.7
  • Usability7.8
How each score was set

Usability 7.8 /10

From published features and owner comments · not a lab test.

Build and specs10.0/10
Every item is published: output and bin, size and weight, materials, a 46 dB rating and ETL/cETL listing.
Warranty and returns9.0/10
Two-year warranty, 30-day refunds, free return shipping under 80 lb and no restocking fee for this size.
Ease of use and cleaning7.0/10
Removable tank, self-clean, dishwasher-safe parts and a manual; no timer, and an owner finds the drain plug awkward.
Price and running costs7.0/10
Sale price with free contiguous-US shipping and no consumables; reference prices vary by page.
Support and owner reports5.0/10
A US phone line and email are listed, but Amazon and Best Buy owners rate this model poorly.

Social 6.7 /10

Average of the independent owner-review sources listed below.

Marketplace reviews5.8/10
Product · 809 reviews · amazon.com
Independent web and YouTube7.5/10
Product · 2 reviews · epicurious.com, thebarbecuelab.com
RedditNot enough data
Searched; not enough owner reviews to score.

Claims we checked

The published claim, then what we found. Live statuses. How we review

The claim

2-Year Warranty Included

What we found

Verified

Product page and site banner both state two years.

Source · checked Nov 15, 2026

The claim

FREE Return Shipping

What we found

Fine print

Free only for items under 80 lb bought on newair.com; original shipping is not refunded.

Source · checked Nov 15, 2026

The claim

Produces up to 44 lbs of ice each day

What we found

Fine print

The Barbecue Lab's 60-minute test works out to about 38.5 lb/day with hourly emptying.

Source · checked Nov 15, 2026
Tiers

Where a score sits among everything scored in the same category:

Needs at least 2 scored in the category.

How we review →
Social score

The average of independent owner-review sources (for example Reddit, Trustpilot and store reviews), weighted for volume and recency. A source with too few reviews is listed as “Not enough data” and left out.

How we review →
Usability score

Published features and terms (price, renewal, refunds, support and the category’s own criteria), each scored against written anchors. Calculated, not lab-tested.

How we review →