Menu
Last updated Nov 13, 2026

How we review

Where the numbers come from, and what they are not.

We don’t test products ourselvesPublic sources onlyBrands can’t pay for a score
1

The short version

Our system analyzes published specs and owner feedback to calculate comparisons. Every score is aggregated from public sources; none comes from hands-on use.

What sellers publish

Seller pages

SpecsTermsWarranty
What owners say in public

Owner feedback

RedditIndependent sites & YouTubeMarketplaces
Usability score

4–5 criteria, each 1–10

needs ≥ 4 criteria
Social score

Average of up to 3 pools

needs ≥ 2 pools
Overall score

Average of the two, to one decimal

Rank

Compared only inside one subcategory

“Best” list

Only when a subcategory has ≥ 8 scored brands

We don’t test products ourselves. Every score is aggregated from public sources; none comes from hands-on use.
2

Tap the ring

Every score on Home Catalog is three rings in one. Tap a ring to see what feeds it.

8.1Overall

Overall = Social + Usability, halved

Average of the two, to one decimal. It only exists when both do.

Social+Usability÷ 2 =Overall
Real numbers from the live Pupsicle review, checked Nov 13, 2026. See the review
3

Usability score

Four or five criteria per product type, each scored 1 to 10 against written anchors, using only what the seller publishes.

Seller pages only

Published specs, terms and warranty pages.

4 or 5 criteria

Picked per product type, each with written anchors for 1 to 10.

No score under 4

A brand needs at least four criteria to get a score.

Where Pupsicle landed on the 1–10 scaleUsability 8.1 · checked Nov 13, 2026

Warranty · 7
Specs + Returns + Upkeep · 8
Price · 10
12345678910
Specs8.0
Price10.0
Returns8.0
Warranty7.0
Upkeep8.0
4

Social score

The average of up to three pools of public owner feedback. A brand needs at least two pools.

Reddit

7.0
out of 10

Independent web and YouTube

8.0
out of 10

Marketplace reviews

9.0
out of 10
Pupsicle: Here the pools land close to the plain average (8.0 → 8.0).

Why some pools count for less EXAMPLE

All three pools count fully.

Not counted: reviews on a brand’s own site

We don’t count reviews shown on a brand’s own site.

Paid creator? We say so

When a creator was paid, the review tells you.

5

Overall score and rank

Ranks compare brands inside one subcategory, never across the whole site.

Top of Dog & Cat on Home Catalog

14KninesDog & Cat brand score
2KopeksDog & Cat brand score
3KurgoDog & Cat brand score
4PawSwingDog & Cat brand score

Brand scores in Dog & Cat, best first, from the live site. Pupsicle shows “#1 of 18 products in Dog & Cat”.

When does a “best” list appear?

Only when a subcategory has at least eight scored brands. Drag to try it. EXAMPLE

No best list yet
6

Not scored

When there isn’t enough published information or owner feedback, the page says “Not scored” and why.

EXAMPLE

Brand name · Not scored

Fewer than four criteria publishedOwner feedback in only one pool

We don’t guess.

No score is better than a made-up one. The page says why it’s missing.

7

Claims we checked

Each review lists a few seller claims and what we found. Each has a source and a date. Guess first, then tap.

VerifiedFine print: true, but with conditionsContradicted by the seller’s own pages
The claim

60-day Happy Dog guarantee, even if used

What we found
Your guess?
Fine print

Refund or replacement is one-time per toy, and the return label cost is deducted from the refund.

Source · checked Nov 13, 2026
The claim

Lifetime warranty

What we found
Your guess?
Fine print

One replacement per year per toy; the toy must be unusable and not cut by hand.

Source · checked Nov 13, 2026

Real claims from the Pupsicle review, with their sources.

8

Money and AI

Two questions people ask. Two short answers.

Brands can’t pay for a score or a rank

Commissions never change either.

CommissionsBrand money
ScoreRank

Affiliate Disclosure

AI helps. A person decides.

AI helps with research and drafting. A person reviews what is published.

ResearchDraftPerson reviewsPublished
9

What else you’ll see on a review

Built from the same public data.

Live

Claims we checked

Seller claims with a source and a date.

Live

Score breakdown

Each criterion and owner pool, with its reason.

Live

Coupon by email

Confirm first. Sent by EmailerPros.

Live

More in this category

Other brands in the subcategory, by brand score.

10

More on how we review

Which products we pick, when a list appears, and what the dates mean.

Which products we review

For each brand we review its main products: one when a brand sells a single product or service, up to three for most brands, and never more than five, even for the biggest. We take one product per product line (sizes, colours and bundles count as one), starting with the line’s flagship or best seller, then the products with the most independent owner reviews and the most searches. Accessories, refills and spare parts are left out.

A brand page lists the products we reviewed, and its other products under “Also sells”, without a score.

Rankings

A “best” list ranks the best-scoring product of each brand, so a brand appears once. We publish a list only when at least eight brands in a subcategory are scored: the top 3 at 8 to 14 brands, the top 5 at 15 to 29, and the top 10 at 30 or more.

Sources and prices

Every criterion, owner-feedback pool and checked claim has its source. Prices come from the brand’s own site, with the date we saw them; prices change, so check the seller’s page before you buy.

Dates

The “Updated” date is the day we last checked a review’s sources, not the day the page was edited.